Whuch Stores More Energy - Stiff or Elastic Materials

The energy stored per unit volume as a string or wire is stretched is the area under a stress strain graph.
Suppose we have a steel cable and an elastic cable, both with the same cross sectional area. For a given force the elastic and steel cables will both be subject to the same stress ( 
\[Sires = \frac{Force}{Cross Sectional Area}\]
  ), but the elastic cable will have a higher strain ( 
\[Strain=\frac{Extension}{Original Length}\]
  ) so will store more energy.

For a numerical analysis, suppose the elastic cable is stretched by 25% of its length, and the steel cable is stretched by 0.2% for the same force. Then  
\[x_{Elastic}=0.25l , \: x_{Steel} =0.002 l\]
\[ =k_{Elastic} x_{Elastic}\]

\[F =k_{Steel} x_{Steel}\]

\[k_{Elastic} x_{Elastic} =k_{Steel} x_{Steel} \rightarrow \frac{k_{Steel}}{k_{Elastic}} = \frac{x_{Elastic}}{x_{Steel}} \]
The energy stored in each is
\[ E_{Elastic}=\frac{1}{2}k_{Elastic} x^2_{Elastic}\]

\[E_{Steel} = \frac{1}{2} k_{Steel} x^2_{Steel}\]

\[ \frac{E_{Elastic}}{k_{Steel}}=\frac{k_{Elastic}}{k_{Steel}} \frac{x^2_{Elastic}}{x^2_{Steel}} = \frac{x_{Steel}}{x_{Elastic}} \frac{x^2_{Elastic}}{x^2_{Steel}}= \frac{x_{Elastic}}{x_{Steel}}=\frac{0.25}{0.002}=125 \]

The elastic cable stores over a hundred times more energy.

Add comment

Security code